|  | | 2009 News and Press Releases | | |
HEADLINE NEWS:
Latest U.S. Export: Securities Class Action Legal Services?
Kevin LaCroix
The D & O Diary. November 2, 2009
_________________________________________________________________________
EXCERPT: In an October 29, 2009 order […], Ontario Court of Justice judge Paul Perell ruled that the direct involvement of the U.S.-based law firm Milberg LLP was permissible in the securities class action lawsuit filed against Timminco Limited and pending before the court. Timminco had been sued in two separate proposed class actions under Part XXIII.1 of the Ontario Securities Act. The first filed action was brought by Toronto-based Kim Orr Barristers P.C. The second was brought later by the London (Ont.)-based Siskinds law firm. Each of the respective law firms filed cross-motions to stay the other action. (The motions were presented as "carriage motions," the purpose of which is "to stay all other present and future class proceedings relating to the subject matter.") The Kim Orr law firm argued that because of its association with Milberg, which it described in its motion papers as "a pre-eminent American class action firm," it is "in the best position to prosecute the action." In a response that the Ontario court characterized as "unkindly," the Siskinds law firm drew attention to the "serious stain on the reputation of Milberg LLP," and also raised concerns about the American law firm’s involvement in an Ontario class action. Calling it a "very difficult decision and a very close call," the Ontario court ruled in favor of the Kim Orr firm and stayed the Siskinds action. The court did observe that the Siskinds firm is "one of the pre-eminent class action firms in Canada." The Kim Orr firm, founded in January 2008 was formed by attorneys from other firms that the court described as "pre-eminent." The Ontario court did note the criminal misconduct in which certain Milberg partners had been involved, but also noted that all of the criminally charged attorneys had left the firm. |
|
|
