ÿþ<HTML><HEAD><TITLE>Touchstone Software Corporation - Securities Class Action</TITLE> <META NAME='DESCRIPTION' CONTENT='<b>Summary:</b> The original complaint was filed alleging the sales of WINCheckIt and WIN '95 Advisor were overstated, because the product sold to distributors was subject to an absolute right of return. In December 1995, Touchstone revealed that it would suffer a large loss for the fourth quarter of 1995 and for the entire year of 1995. Touchstone's stock price fell by as much as 75% after these disclosures. The complaint alleges that Touchstone's 10Q's for the prior three quarters were materially false and misleading because: (1) they were not prepared in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles; (2) they materially overstated the net income and earnings per share; (3) they failed to disclose material problems with sales, orders, and collection of ode sections 25400, 25401, 25402, 25502 and intentional and negligent breach of fiduciary duties. On January 26, 1996, the complaint entitled DARRIN J. CARAMONTA v. LARRY W. DINGUS, ET AL. was filed in United States District Court for the Central District of California, in which Mr. Caramonta, on behalf of himself and all others who purchased the Company's Common Stock between May 2, 1995 and December 21, 1995. On March 13, 1996, and on March 21, 1996, substantially similar actions entitled JACK BODNER v. Larry W. Dingus, et al. and MARC JAFFE v. LARRY W. DINGUS, ET AL., respectively, were also filed in the same Court. On April 17, 1997 the Court entered a "Final Judgment and Order of Dismissal" approving the settlement and dismissing the class action in its entirety. Under the principal terms of the agreement, Touchstone Software Corporation established a settlement fund consisting of $500,000 and 200,000 newly-issues shares of common stock. The Company also adopted a written policy on insider trading.'> <META NAME='KEYWORDS' CONTENT='Touchstone Software Corporation - Securities Class Action, Class Action, Securities'></HEAD> <BODY background='/img/bg.gif' VLINK=#660000 ALINK=#DDDDDD LINK=#330066> <TABLE WIDTH=765> <TR><TD WIDTH=151><IMG SRC='/img/frond2.gif'></TD> <TD ALIGN='left'> <table width='600' border='0' cellspacing='0' cellpadding='0'> <tr> <td height='75'><img src='/img/scac_banner_600.jpg' width='600' height='85' usemap='#MapMapMap' border='0'><map name='MapMapMap'><area shape='rect' coords='338,56,591,77' href='http://www.cornerstone.com'><area shape='rect' coords='7,4,232,36' href='http://www.law.stanford.edu/'></map></td> </tr> <tr bgcolor='#330066'> <td height='35'> <table width='600' border='0' cellspacing='6' cellpadding='0' bgcolor='#330066' height='20'> <tr bgcolor='#330066'> <td height='20' width='297'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' size=4 color=#330066><b><font color='#FFFFFF'>Company and Case Information</font></b></font></td> <td height='20' width='285'> <div align='right'><b><font face='Garmond, Helvetica, Times' size='1' color='#660000'><font color='#FFFFFF'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times'> </font></font><a href='##' onClick='window.open ('/warning/disclaimer.htm', 'avance', 'toolbar=no,location=no,directories=no,status=no,menubar=no,scrollbars=no, resizable=no,valign=middle,align=center,width=480,h eight=465');'><font color='#FFFFFF'>IMPORTANT INFORMATION</font></a><font color='#FFFFFF'> | <a href='/search.shtml'><font color='#FFFFFF'></font></a></font><a href='/companies.html'><font color='#FFFFFF'>INDEX OF FILINGS</font></a><font color='#FFFFFF'> | <a href='/search.shtml'><font color='#FFFFFF'>SEARCH</font></a></font><font color='#FFFFFF'><a href='/search.shtml'></a></font><font color='#FFFFFF'><a href='/search.shtml'></a></font></font></b></div> </td> </tr> </table> </td> </tr> </table> </TD></TR> <TR><TD VALIGN='top'> <table width='136' border='0' cellspacing='7' cellpadding='0' height='558'> <tr valign='top' bgcolor='#330066'> <td height='770'> <p><font size='2' color='#000000'><font size='3' color='#FFFFFF'><a href='/index.html'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' color='#FFFFFF'>Home<br> <br> </font></a><a href='/companies.html'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' color='#FFFFFF'>Index of Filings</font></a><a href='/decisions.html'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times'> </font></a><br> </font></font><br> <font size='3' color='#000000'><font color='#FFFFFF'><font size='3'><a href='/news.html'><font face='Garmond, Helvetica, Times' color='#FFFFFF'>News and Press Releases</font></a></font><br> </font></font><font size='3' color='#000000'><font color='#FFFFFF'><br> <a href='/filing.html'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' color='#FFFFFF'>Filings</font></a></font></font></p> <p><font size='3' color='#000000'><font color='#FFFFFF'><a href='/decisions.html'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' color='#FFFFFF'>Decisions</font></a></font></font></p> <p><font size='3' color='#000000'><font color='#FFFFFF'><a href='/research.html'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' color='#FFFFFF'></font></a></font><font size='3' color='#000000'><font color='#FFFFFF'><a href='/settle.html'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' color='#FFFFFF'>Settlements<br> </font></a></font></font></font></p> <p><font size='3' color='#000000'><font color='#FFFFFF'> </font></font><font size='3' color='#000000'><font color='#FFFFFF'><a href='/litigation_activity.html'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' color='#FFFFFF'>Litigation Activity Indices</font></a><br> </font></font></p> <p><font size='3' color='#000000'><font size='3' color='#000000'><font color='#FFFFFF'><a href='/top_ten_list.html'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' color='#FFFFFF'>Top Ten List</font></a></font></font></font></p> <p><font size='3' color='#000000'><font color='#FFFFFF'><a href='/annual_quarterly_updates.html'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' color='#FFFFFF'>Annual/Quarterly Updates</font></a> </font></font><font size='3'><br> <br> <font color='#000000'><font color='#FFFFFF'><a href='/clearinghouse_research.html'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' color='#FFFFFF'>Clearinghouse Research</font></a> </font></font><br> <a href='/news.html'><font face='Garmond, Helvetica, Times' color='#FFFFFF'><br> </font></a></font><font size='3' color='#000000'><font color='#FFFFFF'><a href='/research.html'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' color='#FFFFFF'>Articles & Papers</font><br> </a><a href='/lr.html'> <font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' color='#FFFFFF'> <br> </font></a><a href='/search.shtml'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' color='#FFFFFF'>Search</font></a> <br> <a href='/sites.html'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' color='#FFFFFF'><br> Related Sites</font></a><a href='/sponsor.html'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times'><br> </font></a></font></font></p> <p><font size='3' color='#000000'><font color='#FFFFFF'><a href='/email.html'><font size='3' color='#000000'><font color='#FFFFFF'></font></font></a><font size='3' color='#000000'><font color='#FFFFFF'><a href='/lr.html'><font size='3' color='#000000'><font color='#FFFFFF'></font></font></a><font size='3' color='#000000'><font color='#FFFFFF'><a href='/email.html'><font size='3' color='#000000'><font color='#FFFFFF'></font></font></a><font size='3' color='#000000'><font color='#FFFFFF'><a href='/info.html'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' color='#FFFFFF'>About Us<br> </font></a><a href='/search.shtml'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' color='#FFFFFF'></font></a></font></font><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' color='#FFFFFF'></font></font></font><br> <a href='/lr.html'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' color='#FFFFFF'>Local Rules</font></a><br> <a href='/info.html'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' color='#FFFFFF'><br> </font></a></font></font><a href='/sponsor.html'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' color='#FFFFFF'>Sponsors</font></a></font><a href='/sponsor.html'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times'><br> </font></a></font><br> <font size='3' color='#000000'><font color='#FFFFFF'><a href='/email.html'><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' color='#FFFFFF'>Register</font></a></font></font></p> <p><font color='#000000'><img src='/img/nullbar.gif' width='120' height='8'></font><br> <font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' size='1' color='#FFFFFF'><b>_______________<br> </b></font><font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' size='1' color='#FFFFFF'><b>Copyright (c) 2001<br> Stanford Law School </b></font> </p> </td> </tr> </table> </TD><TD valign='top'><br><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=4 color=#330066><B> Touchstone Software Corporation</B><font size=2> <form method='get' action='http://find.stanford.edu/search'> <input type='text' name='q' size='40' maxlength='255' value=''/> <font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' size=2 color=#330066><b><font size=1> <input type='submit' name='btnG' value='SEARCH CASE COURT FILINGS'/> </font></b></font> <input type='hidden' name='site' value='stanford'/> <input type='hidden' name='client' value='stanford'/> <input type='hidden' name='proxystylesheet' value='http://google.stanford.edu/stylesheet.xslt'/> <input type='hidden' name='output' value='xml_no_dtd'/> <input type='hidden' name='as_dt' value='i'/> <input type='hidden' name='as_sitesearch' value='http://securities.stanford.edu/1007/TSSW96'> </form> </font></font> <font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066> <b>Conclusion:</b>&nbsp;The original complaint was filed alleging the sales of WINCheckIt and WIN '95 Advisor were overstated, because the product sold to distributors was subject to an absolute right of return. In December 1995, Touchstone revealed that it would suffer a large loss for the fourth quarter of 1995 and for the entire year of 1995. Touchstone's stock price fell by as much as 75% after these disclosures. The complaint alleges that Touchstone's 10Q's for the prior three quarters were materially false and misleading because: (1) they were not prepared in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles; (2) they materially overstated the net income and earnings per share; (3) they failed to disclose material problems with sales, orders, and collection of ode sections 25400, 25401, 25402, 25502 and intentional and negligent breach of fiduciary duties. <br><br> On January 26, 1996, the complaint entitled DARRIN J. CARAMONTA v. LARRY W. DINGUS, ET AL. was filed in United States District Court for the Central District of California, in which Mr. Caramonta, on behalf of himself and all others who purchased the Company's Common Stock between May 2, 1995 and December 21, 1995. On March 13, 1996, and on March 21, 1996, substantially similar actions entitled JACK BODNER v. Larry W. Dingus, et al. and MARC JAFFE v. LARRY W. DINGUS, ET AL., respectively, were also filed in the same Court. <br><br> On April 17, 1997 the Court entered a "Final Judgment and Order of Dismissal" approving the settlement and dismissing the class action in its entirety. Under the principal terms of the agreement, Touchstone Software Corporation established a settlement fund consisting of $500,000 and 200,000 newly-issues shares of common stock. The Company also adopted a written policy on insider trading.<br> <HR WIDTH=50% ALIGN=left> INDUSTRY CLASSIFICATION:<br> <b>SIC Code:</b> 7372<br> <b>Sector:</b> Technology<br> <b>Industry:</b> Software & Programming<br> </font><p></P><HR> <TABLE width='100%'> <TR> <TD ALIGN='left' width='30%'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=1 color=#330066><B> COMPANY/ISSUER NAME:</B></font></TD> <TD ALIGN='left'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066><B> Touchstone Software Corporation</B></font></TD> </TR> <TR> <TD ALIGN='left' width='30%'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=1 color=#330066><B> COMPANY/ISSUER TICKER:</B></font></TD> <TD ALIGN='left'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066><B> TSSW</B></font></TD> </TR> <TR> <TD ALIGN='left' width='30%'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=1 color=#330066><B> COMPANY WEBSITE:</B></font></TD> <TD ALIGN='left'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066><B> <A HREF='http://www.touchstonesoftware.com/'>http://www.touchstonesoftware.com/</A></B></font></TD> </TR> </TABLE><HR> <TABLE BORDER=0 width=100%> <TR><TD COLSPAN = 4><B><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066> FIRST IDENTIFIED COMPLAINT IN THE DATABASE</font></B></TD></TR> <TR><TD colspan=4 align='left' bgcolor='#330066'> <font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#FFFFFF><B>Darrin J. Caramonta, et al. v. Touchstone Software Corporation, et al.</B></font></TD></TR> <TR><TD align='left' colspan='4'><div align='left'> <table width='100%' CELLPADDING='0' CELLSPACING='0' BORDER='1'> <TR><TD align='left'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066> &nbsp;COURT:&nbsp;<b>C.D. California</b></font></TD> <TD ALIGN='left'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066> &nbsp;DOCKET NUMBER:&nbsp;<b>96-CV-00081</b><font></font></font></TD></TR> <TR><TD align='left' colspan=2 bgcolor='#DDDDDD'> <font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066> &nbsp;JUDGE NAME:&nbsp;<b>Hon. Gary L. Taylor</b></font></TD></TR> <TR><TD align='left'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066> &nbsp;DATE FILED:&nbsp;<b>01/26/1996</b></font></TD> <TD align='left'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066> &nbsp;SOURCE:&nbsp;<b>Other<b></b></b></font></TD></TR> <TR><TD align='left' bgcolor='#DDDDDD'> <font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066> &nbsp;CLASS PERIOD START:&nbsp;<b>05/02/1995<b></b></b></font></td> <TD align='left' bgcolor='#DDDDDD'> <font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066> &nbsp;CLASS PERIOD END:&nbsp;<b>12/21/1995</b></font></TD></TR> <TR><TD align='left' colspan=2><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066> &nbsp;TYPE OF COMPLAINT:&nbsp;<b>Complaint (Unamended and Unconsolidated)</b></font></TD></TR> <TR><TD align='left' colspan=2 bgcolor='#DDDDDD'> <font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066> &nbsp;PLAINTIFF FIRMS NAMED IN COMPLAINT:</font></TD></TR> <TR><TD align='left' colspan=2><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066><LI> <A HREF=''>Dyer, Donnelly & Lilly</A><BR>&nbsp;&nbsp;825 Logan Street, Denver, , 80203-3114<BR> &nbsp;&nbsp; (voice) 303.861.3003, (fax) , <LI> <A HREF='http://www.milbergweiss.com '>Milberg Weiss Bershad Hynes & Lerach LLP (Los Angeles, CA)</A><BR>&nbsp;&nbsp;355 S Grand Ave - Ste 4170, Los Angeles, CA, 90071-3172<BR> &nbsp;&nbsp; (voice) 213.617.9007, (fax) , <LI> <A HREF='http://www.milberg.com '>Milberg Weiss Bershad Hynes & Lerach LLP (San Diego, CA)</A><BR>&nbsp;&nbsp;600 West Broadway, 1800 One America Plaza, San Diego, CA, 92101<BR> &nbsp;&nbsp; (voice) 800.449.4900, (fax) , support@milberg.com <BR> <font face='Garmond,Helvetica,Times' size=1 color='#330066'> _____________________________________________ </font><BR> &nbsp;TOTAL NUMBER OF PLAINTIFF FIRMS:&nbsp; <b>3</b></font></TD></tr> </table></div> </TD></TR> </TABLE> <BR> <TABLE CELLPADDING=0 CELLSPACING=0 BORDER=1 width=100%> <TR><TD COLSPAN=4 bgcolor=#330066><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#FFFFFF> &nbsp;DOCUMENTS FOR THE FIRST IDENTIFIED COMPLAINT</font></TD></TR><TR> <TD COLSPAN=4 bgcolor=#DDDDDD><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066><b><A HREF='/1007/TSSW96/001.html'>Class Action Complaint for Violations of the Federal Securities Laws and the Cal. Corp. Code; Verified Derivative Complaint for Breach of Fiduciary Duty and Violation of the Cal. Corp. Code</A></b></font> </TD> </TR> <TR> <TD COLSPAN=2 align='left'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066>Type:&nbsp;Complaint</font> </TD> <TD COLSPAN=2 align='left'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066>Date on the document:&nbsp;01/26/1996</font> </TD> </TR><TR> <TD COLSPAN=4 bgcolor=#DDDDDD><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066><b><A HREF='/1007/TSSW96/mof.html'>Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Preliminary Injunction To Freeze Assets</A></b></font> </TD> </TR> <TR> <TD COLSPAN=2 align='left'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066>Type:&nbsp;Other</font> </TD> <TD COLSPAN=2 align='left'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066>Date on the document:&nbsp;03/11/1996</font> </TD> </TR><TR> <TD COLSPAN=4 bgcolor=#DDDDDD><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066><b><A HREF='/1007/TSSW96/smo.html'>Sur-Reply Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Preliminary Injunction To Freeze Assets</A></b></font> </TD> </TR> <TR> <TD COLSPAN=2 align='left'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066>Type:&nbsp;Other</font> </TD> <TD COLSPAN=2 align='left'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066>Date on the document:&nbsp;03/25/1996</font> </TD> </TR><TR> <TD COLSPAN=4 bgcolor=#DDDDDD><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066><b><A HREF='/1007/TSSW96/rsm.html'>Defendants' Response to Plaintiff's Post-Hearing Supplemental Memorandum in Opposition to Defendants' Motion To Dismiss</A></b></font> </TD> </TR> <TR> <TD COLSPAN=2 align='left'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066>Type:&nbsp;Other</font> </TD> <TD COLSPAN=2 align='left'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066>Date on the document:&nbsp;05/06/1996</font> </TD> </TR><TR> <TD COLSPAN=4 bgcolor=#DDDDDD><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066><b><A HREF='/1007/TSSW96/rms.html'>Reply Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of Defendants' Motion To Dismiss Pursuant to FRCP 12(B)(6) and 9(B)</A></b></font> </TD> </TR> <TR> <TD COLSPAN=2 align='left'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066>Type:&nbsp;Other</font> </TD> <TD COLSPAN=2 align='left'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066>Date on the document:&nbsp;05/06/1996</font> </TD> </TR><TR> <TD COLSPAN=4 bgcolor=#DDDDDD><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066><b><A HREF='/1007/TSSW96/msd.html'>Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of Defendants' Motion To Dismiss Pursuant to FRCP 12(B)(6) and 9(B)</A></b></font> </TD> </TR> <TR> <TD COLSPAN=2 align='left'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066>Type:&nbsp;Other</font> </TD> <TD COLSPAN=2 align='left'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066>Date on the document:&nbsp;09/16/1996</font> </TD> </TR><TR> <TD COLSPAN=4 bgcolor=#DDDDDD><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066><b><A HREF='/1007/TSSW96/1997417_r07k_96CV81.pdf'>U.S. District Court Civil Docket</A></b></font> </TD> </TR> <TR> <TD COLSPAN=2 align='left'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066>Type:&nbsp;Docket</font> </TD> <TD COLSPAN=2 align='left'><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066>Date on the document:&nbsp;04/17/1997</font> </TD> </TR></TABLE><BR> <TABLE CELLPADDING=0 CELLSPACING=0 BORDER=1 width=100%><TR><TD COLSPAN=4 bgcolor=#330066><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#FFFFFF> &nbsp;OTHER DOCUMENTS</font></TD></TR><TR><TD COLSPAN=4 bgcolor=#DDDDDD> <font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066><b> <A HREF='//'></A></b></font></TD></TR> <TR><TD COLSPAN=4 align='left'> <font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066> Case Name and/or Number:&nbsp;</font> </TD></TR> <TR> <TD COLSPAN=2 align='left'> <font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066> Type:&nbsp;</font></TD> <TD COLSPAN=2 align='left'> <font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066> Date on the document:&nbsp;</font></TD> </TR></TABLE> <font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=2 color=#330066> <HR><b>WARNING AND DISCLAIMER OF LIABILITY:</b><br> The information included on this Web site, whether provided by personnel employed by Stanford Law School or by third parties, is provided for research and teaching purposes only. Neither Stanford University, Stanford Law School, nor any of their employees, agents, contractors, or affiliates warrant the accuracy or completeness of the information or analyses displayed herein, and we caution all readers that inclusion of any information on this site does not constitute an endorsement of the truthfulness or accuracy of that information. In particular, this Web site contains complaints and other documents filed in federal and state courts, which make allegations that may or may not be accurate. No reader should, on the basis of information contained in or referenced by this Web site, assume that any of these allegations are truthful. <HR> </font> <font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=1 color=#330066> Go to <A HREF='/search.shtml'> <font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=1 color=#330066>Search</font></A> &nbsp;page |</font> <font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=1 color=#330066> Go to <A HREF='/companies.html'> <font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=1 color=#330066>Case Index</font></A> &nbsp;page |</font> <font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=1 color=#330066> Back to <A HREF=#top><font FACE=Garmond,Helvetica,Times size=1 color=#330066> Top</font></A><BR><BR></font><BR> </TD></TR></TABLE></BODY></HTML>