Docket as of October 21, 1999 [retrieved 10/26/99]
Proceedings include all events. TERMED
4:97cv3495 Copperstone, et al v. TCSI Corporation, et al
TERMED
U.S. District Court
U.S. District for the Northern District of California (Oakland)
CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 97-CV-3495
Copperstone, et al v. TCSI Corporation, et al Filed: 09/24/97
Assigned to: Judge Saundra Brown Armstrong Jury demand: Plaintiff
Demand: $0,000 Nature of Suit: 850
Lead Docket: None Jurisdiction: Federal Question
Dkt# in other court: None
Cause: 15:78m(a) Securities Exchange Act
[Party and Counsel List]
9/24/97 1 COMPLAINT Fee status pd entered on 9/24/97 in the amount
of $ 150.00 ( Receipt No. 44017); jury demand
[4:97-cv-03495] (oh) [Entry date 09/26/97]
9/24/97 2 NOTICE by Plaintiff Albert J. Copperstone, Plaintiff Joseph
Siciliano to preserve documents pursuant to Local Rule
16-1(g)(4) [4:97-cv-03495] (oh) [Entry date 09/26/97]
9/24/97 3 NOTICE by Plaintiff Albert J. Copperstone, Plaintiff Joseph
Siciliano of Local Rule 3-13 notice of pendency of other
action in California Superior Court [4:97-cv-03495] (oh)
[Entry date 09/26/97]
9/24/97 4 ORDER RE COURT PROCEDURE and SCHEDULE by Judge Saundra B.
Armstrong : Proof of service to be filed by 11/10/97 ;
counsels' case management statement to be filed by 1/20/98 ;
initial case management conference will be held 3:00
1/28/98 . (cc: all counsel) (oh) [Entry date 09/26/97]
9/29/97 5 NOTICE by Plaintiff of publication [4:97-cv-03495] (oh)
[Entry date 09/30/97]
10/31/97 6 WAIVER OF SERVICE by defendant TCSI Corporation, defendant
Harvey E. Wagner, defendant Harish S. Rao, defendant Roger
A. Strauch, defendant Daniel H. Miller, defendant John C.
Bolger, defendant Ram A. Banin, defendant William A.
Hasler, defendant David G. Messerschmitt, defendant Paul A.
Farmer served on 10/15/97 in response to the Request for
Waiver sent on 9/30/97 [4:97-cv-03495] (oh)
[Entry date 11/03/97]
11/24/97 7 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION WITH MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND
AUTHORITIES by Plaintiff for appointment of lead
plaintiffs & approval of plaintiffs' selection of co-lead
counsel with Notice set for 3/10/98 at 2pm [4:97-cv-03495]
(mh) [Entry date 11/25/97]
11/24/97 8 DECLARATION by David R. Stickney on behalf of Plaintiffs in
support of the motion for appointment of lead plaintiffs &
approval of plaintiffs' selection of co-lead counsel [7-1]
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 11/25/97]
11/24/97 9 CERTIFICATE by Plaintiffs pursuant to Local Rule 3-7A(d)
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 11/25/97]
11/24/97 -- RECEIVED Proposed Order (Plaintiffs) re: motion for
appointment of lead plaintiffs & approval of plaintiffs'
selection of co-lead counsel [7-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 11/25/97]
12/16/97 10 STATEMENT of non-opposition by defendant TCSI Corporation,
defendant Roger A. Strauch, defendant Daniel H. Miller,
defendant C. Bolger, defendant Ram A. Banin, defendant
William A. Hasler, defendant David G. Messerschmitt,
defendant Paul A. Farmer to motion for appointment of lead
plaintiffs & approval of plaintiffs' selection of co-lead
counsel [7-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 12/24/97]
12/16/97 11 PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant TCSI Corporation, defendant
Roger A. Strauch, defendant Daniel H. Miller, defendant
John C. Bolger, defendant Ram A. Banin, defendant William
A. Hasler, defendant David G. Messerschmitt, defendant Paul
A. Farmer of statement [10-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
[Entry date 12/24/97]
12/18/97 12 STATEMENT of non-opposition by defendant Harvey E. Wagner
to motion for appointment of lead plaintiffs & approval of
plaintiffs' selection of co-lead counsel [7-1]
[4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 12/24/97]
12/18/97 13 STATEMENT of non-opposition by defendant Harish S. Rao to
motion for appointment of lead plaintiffs & approval of
plaintiffs' selection of co-lead counsel [7-1]
[4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 12/24/97]
1/14/98 14 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION before Judge Saundra B.
Armstrong by defendant Harvey E. Wagner to dismiss
complaint with Notice set for 2:00 p.m. on 3/10/98
[4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
1/14/98 15 PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant TCSI Corporation, defendant
Roger A. Strauch, defendant Daniel H. Miller, defendant
John C. Bolger, defendant Ram A. Banin, defendant William
A. Hasler, defendant David G. Messerschmitt, defendant Paul
A. Farmer of stipulation and order [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
1/15/98 16 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION before Judge Saundra B.
Armstrong by defendant TCSI Corporation, defendant Roger A.
Strauch, defendant Daniel H. Miller, defendant John C.
Bolger, defendant Ram A. Banin, defendant William A. Hasler
defendant David G. Messerschmitt, defendant Paul A. Farmer
to dismiss complaint with Notice set for 2:00 p.m. on
3/10/98 [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 01/16/98]
1/15/98 17 DECLARATION by Christine A. Kendrick on behalf of defendant
TCSI Corporation, defendant Roger A. Strauch, defendant
Paul A. Farmer in support of motion to dismiss complaint
[16-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 01/16/98]
1/15/98 -- RECEIVED Proposed Order ( defendant TCSI Corporation,
defendant Roger A. Strauch, defendant Paul A. Farmer ) re:
motion to dismiss complaint [16-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
[Entry date 01/16/98]
1/15/98 18 PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant TCSI Corporation, defendant
Roger A. Strauch, defendant Paul A. Farmer of order
received [0-0], declaration [17-1], motion to dismiss
complaint [16-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 01/16/98]
1/15/98 19 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION before Judge Saundra B.
Armstrong by defendant Harish S. Rao to dismiss complaint
with Notice set for 9:00 a.m. on 3/10/98 [4:97-cv-03495]
(mmr) [Entry date 01/16/98]
1/15/98 20 REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE by defendant Harish S. Rao and
index of exhibits [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
[Entry date 01/16/98]
1/15/98 -- RECEIVED Proposed Order ( defendant Harish S. Rao ) re:
motion to dismiss complaint [19-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
[Entry date 01/16/98]
1/15/98 21 PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant Harish S. Rao of order
received [0-0], request [20-1], motion to dismiss complaint
[19-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 01/16/98]
1/22/98 22 CLERK'S NOTICE Case Management Conference set for 1/28/98
is moved to 2:00 p.m. on 3/10/98 [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
[Entry date 01/23/98]
1/23/98 23 ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong Case Management
Conference set for 3/10/98 is moved to 2:30 p.m. on 1/28/98
telephonically ( Date Entered: 1/25/98) (cc: all counsel)
[4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 01/26/98]
1/29/98 24 STIPULATION by dfts to serve their motions no later than
1/14/98, pla's oppositon shall be served by 2/12/98, dfts
shall serve replies by 2/26/98, oral argument shall be held
on 3/10/98. [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 01/30/98]
1/29/98 25 ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong Case Management
Conference set for 1/28/98 is continued to 2:15 p.m. on
2/4/98 telephonically ( Date Entered: 1/30//98) (cc: all
counsel) [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 01/30/98]
2/3/98 26 Joint CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT filed. [4:97-cv-03495]
(mmr) [Entry date 02/04/98]
2/4/98 27 EX-PARTE APPLICATION before Judge Saundra B. Armstrong by
Plaintiff Albert J. Copperstone, Plaintiff Joseph Siciliano
for leave to file a single brief, not to exceed 50 pages,
in opposition to dfts' motion to dimiss [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
2/4/98 28 DECLARATION by David Stickney on behalf of Plaintiff Albert
J. Copperstone, Plaintiff Joseph Siciliano in support of
motion for leave to file a single brief, not to exceed 50
pages, in opposition to dfts' motion to dimiss [27-1]
[4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
2/5/98 29 ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong granting motion for
leave to file a single brief, not to exceed 50 pages, in
opposition to dfts' motion to dimiss [27-1] ( Date Entered:
2/5/98) (cc: all counsel) [4:97-cv-03495] (scu)
2/9/98 30 ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong Case Management
Conference continued to 2:30 p.m. on 2/19/98 telephonically
( Date Entered: 2/10/98) (cc: all counsel)
[4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 02/10/98]
2/11/98 31 CLERK'S NOTICE Case Management Conference set for 2/19/98
is moved to 3:00 p.m. on 2/19/98 telephonically
[4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
2/18/98 32 Joint CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT filed. [4:97-cv-03495]
(mmr)
2/18/98 33 STIPULATION and ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong :
contnuing hearing on motion to dismiss complaint [19-1] to
2:00 p.m. on 5/12/98, continuing hearing on motion to
dismiss complaint [16-1] to 2:00 p.m. on 5/12/98,
continuing hearing on motion to dismiss complaint [14-1] to
2:00 p.m. on 5/12/98; pla's response to motions is due by
2/19/98, dfts' replies are due by 3/12/98 (cc: all counsel)
[4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 02/19/98]
2/19/98 34 MINUTES: ( C/R not reported) ( Hearing Date: 2/19/98) Case
Management Conference held, parties to submit briefs
[4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 02/20/98]
2/20/98 35 OBJECTIONS by Plaintiff Albert J. Copperstone, Plaintiff
Joseph Siciliano to consideration of dfts 1996 and 1997
proxy statements [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
2/20/98 35 Counter-MOTION by Plaintiff Albert J. Copperstone,
Plaintiff Joseph Siciliano to strike exhibits K and L to
the declaration [17-1] with notice set for 2:00 p.m. on
5/12/98 [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
2/20/98 36 Consolidated OPPOSITION by Plaintiff Albert J. Copperstone,
Plaintiff Joseph Siciliano to motion to dismiss complaint
[19-1], motion to dismiss complaint [16-1], motion to
dismiss complaint [14-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
2/20/98 37 DECLARATION by Jeffrey M. Lawrence on behalf of Plaintiff
Albert J. Copperstone, Plaintiff Joseph Siciliano iin
support of consolidated opposition [36-1] [4:97-cv-03495]
(mmr)
3/2/98 38 MEMORANDUM by defendants in support of class certification
before adjudication of the motion to dismiss
[4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 03/03/98]
3/2/98 39 PROOF OF SERVICE by defendants of memorandum [38-1]
[4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 03/03/98]
3/2/98 40 MEMORANDUM by Plaintiff Albert J. Copperstone, Plaintiff
Joseph Siciliano in support of deferring the class
certification until after the resolution of dfts' motion to
dismiss [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 03/03/98]
3/5/98 41 ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong granting motion for
appointment of lead plaintiffs & approval of plaintiffs'
selection of co-lead counsel [7-1] ( Date Entered: 3/9/98)
(cc: all counsel) [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
[Entry date 03/09/98]
3/6/98 42 ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong continuing Case
Management Conference to 2:00 p.m. on 5/12/98 ( Date
Entered: 3/9/98) (cc: all counsel) [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
[Entry date 03/09/98]
3/6/98 43 NOTICE by defendant TCSI Corporation, defendant Roger A.
Strauch, defendant Daniel H. Miller, defendant John C.
Bolger, defendant Ram A. Banin, defendant William A.
Hasler, defendant David G. Messerschmitt, defendant Paul A.
Farmer of entry of order [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
[Entry date 03/09/98]
3/9/98 44 MAIL [42-2] returned from Post Office [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
3/9/98 45 PROOF OF SERVICE by Plaintiff Albert J. Copperstone,
Plaintiff Joseph Siciliano of order [41-1] [4:97-cv-03495]
(mmr) [Entry date 03/12/98]
3/12/98 46 STIPULATION and ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong :
setting hearing on motion to dismiss complaint [19-1] for
2:00 p.m. on 5/12/98, setting hearing on motion to dismiss
complaint [16-1] for 2:00 p.m. on 5/12/98, setting hearing
on motion to dismiss complaint [14-1] for 2:00 p.m. on
5/12/98 (cc: all counsel) [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
[Entry date 03/13/98]
3/19/98 47 REPLY by defendant Harvey E. Wagner to plas' consolidated
opposition [36-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
[Entry date 03/20/98]
3/20/98 48 REPLY by defendant TCSI Corporation, defendant Roger A.
Strauch, defendant Daniel H. Miller, defendant John C.
Bolger, defendant Ram A. Banin, defendant William A.
Hasler, defendant David G. Messerschmitt, defendant Paul A.
Farmer in support of motion to dismiss complaint [16-1]
[4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 03/24/98]
3/20/98 49 REPLY by defendant TCSI Corporation, defendant Roger A.
Strauch, defendant Daniel H. Miller, defendant John C.
Bolger, defendant Ram A. Banin, defendant William A.
Hasler, defendant David G. Messerschmitt, defendant Paul A.
Farmer in support of notice [43-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
[Entry date 03/24/98]
3/20/98 50 DECLARATION by Christine A. Kendrick on behalf of defendant
TCSI Corporation, defendant Roger A. Strauch, defendant
Daniel H. Miller, defendant John C. Bolger, defendant Ram
A. Banin, defendant William A. Hasler, defendant David G.
Messerschmitt, defendant Paul A. Farmer in support of
motion to dismiss complaint [16-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
[Entry date 03/24/98]
3/20/98 51 PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant TCSI Corporation, defendant
Roger A. Strauch, defendant Daniel H. Miller, defendant
John C. Bolger, defendant Ram A. Banin, defendant William
A. Hasler, defendant David G. Messerschmitt, defendant Paul
A. Farmer of declaration [50-1], reply [49-1], reply [48-1]
[4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 03/24/98]
3/20/98 52 REPLY by defendant TCSI Corporation, defendant Roger A.
Strauch, defendant Daniel H. Miller, defendant John C.
Bolger, defendant Ram A. Banin, defendant William A.
Hasler, defendant David G. Messerschmitt, defendant Paul A.
Farmer in support of motion to dismiss complaint [19-1]
[4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 03/24/98]
3/20/98 52 OPPOSITION by defendant Harish S. Rao to motion to strike
exhibits K and L to the declaration [17-1] [35-1]
[4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 03/24/98]
3/25/98 53 PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant Harish S. Rao of opposition
[52-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 03/30/98]
4/20/98 54 ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong parties shall meet
and confer re: class certification, and submit a
stipulation to the court. Court will reschedule a hearing
on dfts' motion to dismiss upon the court's approval of the
stipulation re: class certification ( Date Entered:
4/22/98) (cc: all counsel) [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
[Entry date 04/22/98]
4/23/98 55 NOTICE by defendant TCSI Corporation, defendant Roger A.
Strauch, defendant Daniel H. Miller, defendant John C.
Bolger, defendant Ram A. Banin, defendant William A.
Hasler, defendant David G. Messerschmitt, defendant Paul A.
Farmer of entry of order [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
[Entry date 04/24/98]
5/11/98 56 PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant TCSI Corporation, defendant
Roger A. Strauch, defendant Daniel H. Miller, defendant
John C. Bolger, defendant Ram A. Banin, defendant William
A. Hasler, defendant David G. Messerschmitt, defendant Paul
A. Farmer of notice of pendency of class action, summary
notice of pendency of class action and proposed order
regarding class notice procedures [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
[Entry date 05/12/98]
5/28/98 57 STIPULATION and ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong :
withdrawing motion to dismiss complaint [19-1], withdrawing
motion to dismiss complaint [16-1], withdrawing motion to
dismiss complaint [14-1] stay enacted int he PSLRA shall
remain in effect (cc: all counsel) [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
[Entry date 06/01/98]
6/15/98 58 ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong setting hearing on
motion to dismiss complaint [19-1] for 11:30 a.m. on
9/22/98, setting hearing on motion to dismiss complaint
[16-1] for 11:30 a.m. on 9/22/98, setting hearing on
motion to dismiss complaint [14-1] for 11:30 a.m. on
9/22/98 ( Date Entered: 6/16/98) (cc: all counsel)
[4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 06/16/98]
6/15/98 59 ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong regarding class notice
procedures ( Date Entered: 6/16/98) (cc: all counsel)
[4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 06/16/98]
6/16/98 60 NOTICE by defendant TCSI Corporation, defendant Roger A.
Strauch, defendant Daniel H. Miller, defendant John C.
Bolger, defendant Ram A. Banin, defendant William A.
Hasler, defendant David G. Messerschmitt, defendant Paul A.
Farmer of entry of order regarding class notice procedures
[4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
6/16/98 61 NOTICE by defendant TCSI Corporation, defendant Roger A.
Strauch, defendant Daniel H. Miller, defendant John C.
Bolger, defendant Ram A. Banin, defendant William A.
Hasler, defendant David G. Messerschmitt, defendant Paul A.
Farmer of entry of order scheduling hearing
[4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
6/16/98 62 NOTICE by Plaintiff Albert J. Copperstone of entry of order
scheduling order [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
6/29/98 -- RECEIVED Proposed Stipulation & Order (Plaintiff)
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 07/01/98]
6/29/98 63 STIPULATION & ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong: The
Notice of Pendency of Class Action shall be amended to read
as follows: All communications regarding this Notice should
be made in writing [SEE DOCUMENT FOR DETAILS] (cc: all
counsel) [4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 07/01/98]
7/1/98 64 LETTER to Judge Armstrong dated 7/1/98 from Law Firm for
dfts TCSI Corporation, Roger A. Strauch, Daniel H. Miller,
John C. Bolger, Ram A. Banin, William A. Hasler, David G.
Messerschmitt, Paul A. Farmer re: motion hearing set for
9/22/98 at 11:30 a.m. is 2nd day of Jewish New Year
[4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 07/02/98]
7/6/98 65 NOTICE by Plaintiffs of entry of order [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
[Entry date 07/09/98]
7/21/98 66 ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong setting hearing on
motion to dismiss complaint [19-1] for 11:30 a.m. on
9/29/98, setting hearing on motion to dismiss complaint
[16-1] for 11:30 a.m. on 9/29/98, setting hearing on motion
to dismiss complaint [14-1] for 11:30 a.m. on 9/29/98 (
Date Entered: 7/22/98) (cc: all counsel) [4:97-cv-03495]
(mmr) [Entry date 07/22/98]
7/22/98 67 NOTICE by defendant TCSI Corporation, defendant Roger A.
Strauch, defendant Daniel H. Miller, defendant John C.
Bolger, defendant Ram A. Banin, defendant William A.
Hasler, defendant David G. Messerschmitt, defendant Paul A.
Farmer of entry of order continuing hearing
[4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 07/23/98]
9/28/98 68 STATEMENT of Recent Decisions by defendant TCSI
Corporation, defendant Roger A. Strauch, defendant Daniel
H. Miller, defendant C. Bolger, defendant Ram A. Banin,
defendant William A. Hasler, defendant David G.
Messerschmitt, defendant Paul A. Farmer in support of
motion to dismiss complaint [16-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
[Entry date 09/29/98]
9/30/98 69 JOINDER by defendant Harish S. Rao in statement of recent
decisions [68-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr) [Entry date 10/01/98]
10/14/98 70 STATEMENT of Recent Decisions by Plaintiff in further
support of opposition [36-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
[Entry date 10/15/98]
11/18/98 71 SUPPLEMENTAL Submission of Authority by Plaintiff Joseph
Siciliano, Plaintiff Albert J. Copperstone in opposition to
defendants' motion to dismiss [4:97-cv-03495] (mmr)
[Entry date 11/19/98]
11/24/98 72 AMENDMENT by Plaintiff to the supplement [71-1]
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 11/24/98]
1/7/99 73 ATTORNEY APPEARANCE for Plaintiff Class Member Alexander
Van Broek by Lawrence W. Schonbrun [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 01/11/99]
1/11/99 74 SUPPLEMENTAL STATEMENT of facts by the TCSI Defendants in
support of motion to dismiss complaint [16-1]
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 01/13/99]
1/15/99 75 NOTICE by Plaintiff Alexander Van Broek of entry of
attorney appearance [73-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 01/19/99]
1/15/99 75 REQUEST by Plaintiff Alexander Van Broek for placement on
service list [4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 01/21/99]
1/19/99 76 ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong denying plaintiff's
counter-motion to strike [17-1] [35-1], granting
defendants' motions to dismiss [19-1], [16-1], & [14-1]
with leave to amend no later than three weeks after the
filing of this order (Date Entered: 1/21/99) (cc: all
counsel) [4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 01/21/99]
1/22/99 77 NOTICE by Plaintiffs re order granting Defendants' motions
to dismiss [76-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 01/26/99]
2/4/99 -- RECEIVED Stipulation & [Proposed] Order submitted by
defendants [4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 02/08/99]
[Edit date 02/08/99]
2/4/99 78 PROOF OF SERVICE by defendants of document received [0-0]
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 02/08/99]
2/5/99 79 STIPULATION & ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong:
Plaintiff shall respond to this Court's 1/19/99 Order, by
serving an Amended Complaint, no later than 2/23/99, If
Plaintiffs serve an Amended Complaint, Defendants shall
answer or otherwise respond no later than 3/16/99 Oral
argument on the motions to dismiss shall beheld at 2:00pm
on 5/18/99 [SEE DOCUMENT FOR DETAILS] (cc: all counsel)
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 02/08/99]
2/10/99 80 NOTICE by defendants [79-3] stipulation & order
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 02/11/99]
2/23/99 81 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION WITH MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND
AUTHORITIES before Judge Saundra B. Armstrong by Plaintiffs
to stay this action, or in the alternative, to extend
time to amend the complaint until completion of discovery in
the state action & allow the use of that discovery to amend
the complaint with Notice set for 4/6/99 at 11:30am
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 02/24/99]
[Edit date 02/26/99]
2/23/99 82 DECLARATION by David R. Stickney on behalf of Plaintiffs re
motion to stay this action [81-1], re motion to extend time
to amended the complaint until completion of discovery in
the state action & allow the use of that discovery to amend
the complaint [81-2] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 02/24/99]
2/23/99 -- RECEIVED Proposed Order (Plaintiffs) re: motion to stay
this action [81-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 02/24/99]
2/23/99 -- RECEIVED Proposed Order (Plaintiffs) re: motion to extend
time to amended the complaint until completion of discovery
in the state action & allow the use of that discovery to
amend the complaint [81-2] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 02/24/99]
2/25/99 83 AMENDED MOTION before Judge Saundra B. Armstrong by
Plaintiffs to stay this action with Notice set for at
11:30am [4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 02/26/99]
3/1/99 84 MOTION before Judge Saundra B. Armstrong by defendants for
entry of judgment of dismissal with prejudice
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 03/01/99]
3/10/99 85 MOTION, before Judge Saundra B. Armstrong, by defendant
Harish S. Rao, for entry of judgment of dismissal with
prejudice. [4:97-cv-03495] (rl) [Entry date 03/15/99]
4/6/99 86 MEMORANDUM by defendant Harvey E. Wagner in opposition to
motion to stay this action [83-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 04/08/99]
4/6/99 87 DECLARATION by Frank E. Merideth, Jr. on behalf of
defendant Harvey E. Wagner in support of the opposition
memorandum [86-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 04/08/99]
4/6/99 88 COUNTER-MOTION by defendant Harvey E. Wagner for voluntary
dismissal with Notice set for 4/27/99 at 11:30am
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 04/08/99]
4/6/99 88 MEMORANDUM by defendant Harvey E. Wagner in support of
motion for voluntary dismissal [88-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 04/08/99]
4/6/99 89 DECLARATION by Frank E. Merideth, Jr. on behalf of
defendant Harvey E. Wagner re motion for voluntary
dismissal [88-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 04/08/99]
4/6/99 -- RECEIVED Proposed Order (defendant Harvey E. Wagner) re:
motion to stay this action [83-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 04/08/99]
4/6/99 -- RECEIVED Proposed Order (defendant Harvey E. Wagner) re:
motion for voluntary dismissal [88-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 04/08/99]
4/6/99 90 JOINDER by defendant Harish S. Rao to the opposition
memorandum [86-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 04/08/99]
4/6/99 91 DECLARATION by Tracy A. Donsky on behalf of defendant Paul
A. Farmer, defendant David G. Messerschmitt, defendant
William A. Hasler, defendant Ram A. Banin, defendant John
C. Bolger, defendant Daniel H. Miller, defendant Roger A.
Strauch, defendant TCSI Corporation re opposition
memorandum [86-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 04/08/99]
4/6/99 92 MEMORANDUM by defendant Paul A. Farmer, defendant David G.
Messerschmitt, defendant William A. Hasler, defendant Ram
A. Banin, defendant John C. Bolger, defendant Daniel H.
Miller, defendant Roger A. Strauch, defendant TCSI
Corporation in opposition to motion to stay this action
[83-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 04/08/99]
4/6/99 -- RECEIVED Proposed Order (TCI Defendants) re: motion to stay
this action [83-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 04/08/99]
4/6/99 93 PROOF OF SERVICE by the TCI Defendants of declaration
[91-1], opposition memorandum [92-1], order received [0-0]
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 04/08/99]
4/6/99 94 ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE re why this case should not be
dismissed for lack of prosecution: by Judge Saundra B.
Armstrong; hearing set for 11:30am on 4/20/99 (cc: all
counsel) [4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 04/08/99]
4/12/99 95 CERTIFICATE OF COUNSEL by Plaintiffs [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 04/13/99]
4/13/99 96 MEMORANDUM by Plaintiffs in opposition to the
counter-motion for voluntary dismissal [88-1]
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 04/14/99]
4/13/99 97 REPLY MEMORANDUM by Plaintiffs to the opposition to the
motion to stay this action [83-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 04/14/99] [Edit date 04/14/99]
4/13/99 98 SECOND DECLARATION by David R. Stickney on behalf of
Plaintiff re motion to stay this action [83-1]
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 04/14/99]
4/14/99 99 RESPONSE by the TCI Defendants re order to show cause
[94-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 04/15/99]
4/15/99 100 CERTIFICATE by defendant Harish S. Rao [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 04/16/99]
4/19/99 101 LETTER to Judge Armstrong dated 4/19/99 from Jerome F.
Birn, JR. requesting that the OSC hearing be postpone until
4/27/99 [4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 04/20/99]
4/19/99 102 CERTIFICATE OF COUNSEL by defendant Harvey E. Wagner
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 04/20/99]
4/20/99 103 ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong Order to Show Cause
hearing is continued to 11:30am on 4/27/99 (Date Entered:
4/21/99) (cc: all counsel) [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 04/21/99]
4/22/99 104 NOTICE by Plaintiff Albert J. Copperstone [103-2] order
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 04/22/99]
4/28/99 -- RECEIVED Stipulation & [Proposed] Order submitted by
Plaintiff re: motion to stay & order to show cause [83-1]
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 04/28/99]
4/30/99 105 STIPULATION & ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong: vacating
the hearing re Plaintiff's motion to stay this action
[83-1] (cc: all counsel) [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 05/03/99]
8/30/99 -- Docket Modification (Administrative) to order [105-1]
vacating [83-1] motion to stay this action [4:97-cv-03495]
(mh) [Entry date 09/03/99]
9/3/99 106 ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong for preliminarily
approving settlement & providing for notice [SEE DOCUMENT
FOR DETAILS] (Date Entered: 9/8/99) (cc: all counsel)
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 09/08/99]
[Edit date 09/08/99]
9/3/99 -- Docket Modification (Administrative) to order [106-2]
Settlement Hearing will be held before this Court at
11:30am on 10/19/99 [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 10/04/99]
9/8/99 107 NOTICE by Plaintiffs of entry of order [106-2]
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 09/10/99]
10/4/99 108 OBJECTIONS by Plaintiffs to the settlement agreement
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 10/05/99]
[Edit date 10/05/99]
10/4/99 108 NOTICE by Plaintiffs of intention to appear at the hearing
on the proposed settlement award of attorneys' fees, costs
& expenses [4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 10/05/99]
10/4/99 109 DECLARATION by Lawrence W. Schonbrun on behalf of
Plaintiffs re notice [108-1], re objection [108-1]
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 10/05/99]
10/12/99 110 MOTION before Judge Saundra B. Armstrong by Plaintiffs
Alexander Van Broek for a telephonic appearance with
Notice set for 10/19/99 at 10:00am [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 10/12/99] [Edit date 10/12/99]
10/12/99 111 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION WITH MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND
AUTHORITIES before Judge Saundra B. Armstrong by Plaintiffs
of final approval of settlement with Notice set for
10/19/99 at 11:30am [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 10/12/99] [Edit date 10/12/99]
10/12/99 112 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION WITH MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND
AUTHORITIES before Judge Saundra B. Armstrong by Plaintiffs
for award of attorneys' fees, for reimbursement of
expenses with Notice set for 10/19/99 at 11:30am
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 10/12/99]
10/12/99 113 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION WITH MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND
AUTHORITIES before Judge Saundra B. Armstrong by Plaintiffs
for order for approval of plan of allocation with Notice
set for 10/19/99 at 11:30am [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 10/12/99]
10/12/99 114 DECLARATION by Keith F. Park on behalf of Plaintiffs re
motion of final approval of settlement [111-1], re motion
for reimbursement of expenses [112-2], re motion for award
of attorneys' fees [112-1], re motion for order for
approval of plan of allocation [113-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 10/12/99]
10/12/99 115 DECLARATION by Keith F. Park on behalf of Plaintiffs re
motion of final approval of settlement [111-1], re motion
for reimbursement of expenses [112-2], re motion for award
of attorneys' fees [112-1], re motion for order for approval
of plan of allocation [113-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 10/12/99] [Edit date 10/12/99]
10/12/99 116 DECLARATION by Cheryl Washington on behalf of Plaintiff re:
mailing of notice of proposed settlement of class action
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 10/12/99]
10/12/99 117 RESPONSE by Plaintiffs to the objection of Lawrence
Schonbrun on behalf of Alexander Van Broek [4:97-cv-03495]
(mh) [Entry date 10/12/99]
10/12/99 118 DECLARATION by Joy Ann Bull on behalf of Plaintiffs in
support of the response [117-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 10/12/99]
10/12/99 -- RECEIVED Proposed Order (Plaintiff Joseph Siciliano,
Plaintiff Albert J. Copperstone, Plaintiff Alexander Van
Broek) re: motion for order for approval of plan of
allocation [113-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 10/12/99]
10/12/99 -- RECEIVED Proposed Order (Plaintiff Joseph Siciliano,
Plaintiff Albert J. Copperstone, Plaintiff Alexander Van
Broek) re: motion for award of attorneys' fees [112-1], re:
motion for reimbursement of expenses [112-2]
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 10/12/99]
10/12/99 -- RECEIVED Proposed Order (Plaintiff Joseph Siciliano,
Plaintiff Albert J. Copperstone, Plaintiff Alexander Van
Broek) re: final judgment & order of dismissal with
prejudice & re: motion of final approval of settlement
[111-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 10/12/99]
[Edit date 10/12/99]
10/13/99 119 RESPONSE by defendant re motion for a telephonic appearance
[110-1] [4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 10/14/99]
10/15/99 120 ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong granting Plaintiff Van
Broek's motion for a telephonic appearance [110-1]
Fairness hearing will be held at 11:30am on 10/19/99;
Plaintiff Broek, may make a telephonic appearance for this
hearing (Date Entered: 10/19/99) (cc: all counsel)
[4:97-cv-03495] (mh) [Entry date 10/19/99]
10/19/99 121 MINUTES: (C/R Candace Yount) (Hearing Date: 10/19/99)
Final approval of settlement hearing held; Court adhere's
to 25% for attorney fees [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 10/21/99]
10/20/99 122 ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong granting motion for
award of attorneys' fees [112-1], granting motion for
reimbursement of expenses [112-2] ( Date Entered: 10/21/99)
(cc: all counsel) [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 10/21/99]
10/20/99 123 ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong granting motion for
order for approval of plan of allocation [113-1] ( Date
Entered: 10/21/99) (cc: all counsel) [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 10/21/99]
10/20/99 124 FINAL JUDGMENT & ORDER by Judge Saundra B. Armstrong
dismissing action with prejudice (Date Entered: 10/21/99)
(cc: all counsel) [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 10/21/99]
10/21/99 125 NOTICE by Plaintiff Joseph Siciliano, Plaintiff Albert J.
Copperstone, Plaintiff Alexander Van Broek of change of
attorneys' firm address [4:97-cv-03495] (mh)
[Entry date 10/21/99]
[END OF DOCKET: 4:97cv3495]